Sunday, March 29, 2015

Threaded Pot

Some things seem simple but take a whole lot of time.  Threading the new on-board potentiometer was one of them.  After deliberating with Nancy we decided that a max speed of 3 mph is good for the on-board control.  The new 1K pot is larger in diameter than the old one.  I had to drill out the SBT frame for it to fit.  I also had to thread the shaft of the pot to 1/4-28 for the wheel.   For hours I tried everything but the die was not catching it would just spin on the ground down champher I had made.  Finally after a nap I remembered something Robb asked, was it a split or solid die?  Well it was solid, I split it, first by removing all the teeth on my hack saw, then with a dremel.  I now had an open die.  Sure enough It was working great, cutting at 28tpi and an oversized shaft first try.   Holding the tip of the potentiometer in a vice grip, and then the bench vice I was able to cut enough threads to mount the wheel in the right spot.
 It did take chasing the threads a few (about an hour) dozen times to get the diameter down to the size needed for the threaded wheel to fit.  It is hand tight until the last three threads, then it has to be worked with a tool.   Tomorrow I will cut off the extra pot length and start wiring the machine.

Saturday, March 21, 2015

Electrical Planning

I set up the controller on the work bench today.

I am trying to set up a good range on the onboard control.  The 5k pot the machine had would go from 0 to 12 MPH in in a 1/3rd of a turn.  Much too fast for that form of control.

Here is some data I gathered from trials...
Start angle, Max speed, Resistor, Pot, Thought
120, 11.8, 0, 5k,  way too fast & narrow range
0, 9.8, 0, 0, what happens with nothing is connected
90, 2, 3.3K, 1K, max speed is too slow, good range
0, 6.2, 2.2K, 1K, good max speed but slow speed is 2.4 mph if start angle was 10 degrees this would be perfect
90, 6, 2.2K 2.5K, this is good, slow end starts late, not sure how to manage.
10, 3, 3K, 1K,  good but slow
110, 4, 2.68, 2.5K  spot on with huge low end deadband

OK I am doing this the silly way.  I have a meter... I should measure across PH and PW and get a table of speeds for each resistance.  With the 5k pot.  My electrical minded brother said I did it wrong. I kept the pot hooked up to the source when I measured, which skewed my readings.  I threw out the suspect data, and after talking with him and realizing that I had similar results as him we did have similar results: 1k deadband at bottom 3k of range and 1k of deadband at top.  Look at the poly lines not the linear ones.  The chart is messy because the experiment was poor.


Note that the controller works backwards, more resistance is full go, no resistances is stop.  Not safe in our mind since we have a tether that can separate (infinite resistance = fasted speed and no way to stop.)

So for on-board control I want a max speed of 4mph, that is 2K Then I need to make up the rest with 3K of fixed resistors. At least that is the theory. I am going to try 3k fixed with 1k pot & 2.5k pot to see which I like better.  I will also try 2.5k fixed with both.  But first dinner....

OK I am back... Added some new values to the table above in Blue
2.68k fixed with a 2.5k pot has a max speed of 4 and 110 degrees of dead band at the zero end.
3k fixed with a 1k pot has a max speed of 3 and about 10 degrees of dead band at zero.
I need to order a pot that will fit in the machine online anyway, I am thinking of getting one each of 1K, 1.5K, 2K, and 2.5K  Then I can play around a bit more to dial in what I want.  I am leaning towards the 3K 1K setup with 3mph max as a good option.  Note that 2.68K & 1K did not stop at the low end, a 2.68 and 1.5 might.

Note:  the pacesetter is really supposed to be center off.  I found out after wiring up the whole machines that I should have worked with both directions when setting the resistor and pot.  I was able to get it to work with what I got but top speed in forward is 4mph and 2 in reverse.  Forward has no deadband, reverse has about 30 degrees.

Saturday, March 07, 2015

Rub the belly

When I see the storage battery truck like this I think of little grey rolling on his back so I can rub his belly.
I started work on the SBT again this afternoon.  I had stopped a while back when I ruined 3 drill bits trying to drill through some bondo.  I used the same hole, just opening up the back side with the dremel and a die grinder bit, that let the bondo flake away and I could finish installing the mudflaps.  I was working on the machine upright, but one of the rivets would not catch.  So I turned it over to see what was going on easier.  Too many thicknesses of metal, I changed rivet sizes to 1/8th inch and it worked fine.  Next I installed the drive axles to check clearance to the mudflaps.  This was the reminder that I failed to purchase a nibbling tool... yet.   Nancy ordered one off ebay today.  

Also ordered today is the wheels, axles and bearings for the two tank cars.  The wheels and axles are coming from mr-motion.net bearings are ebay.  

This mornings task was working on the flatcar boards for the tanks.  Dialing in the height of the blades and learning how to get consistently good work.  I was having trouble that the way I was pushing the boards I was making a taper.  With practice, and lighter cuts I was able to remove the taper and make all the boards consistently 11 to 13 mm thick.  Yes a bit of a range there... but I can deal.  For the math nerds that is 1-3/4 thick scale boards... scale 2x6 boards.  

I am waiting to work on the tankers until my axles come.
I am waiting on the SBT until the nibbler comes.

Next job is to make a stand for the table saw and jointer.

Sunday, March 01, 2015

nozzle and bands

This weekend I spent the time to install the top nozzle and the bands on the tanks.

To start I wandered around the big box construction store picking up items that would make a good cap.  After reviewing options such as sofa glider pucks, electrical covers, and PVC plumbing parts I settled on a 3" PVC cap and a short section of nozzle.   To get this was a 10 foot section of pipe, and two caps.  Then it was back to the store for a 3.25 inch hole saw.  The saw cost more than the pipe.

I started by removing three staves and putting a two by four curved to fit inside as a backer, glued in with gorilla glue and held with nails.

I cut off a six inch section of pipe, and used that to hold the cap and cut it down to a half inch.  Then a whole lot of hand sanding to remove the lettering on top.  I then cut off sections of pipe to use as a nozzle.

This afternoon was setting up and cutting the bands and drilling for studs with two nuts.  The studs started off as one inch long 10-32 bolts cut with the dremel.




Thursday, February 19, 2015

Planning

Here is a picture of my in progress tank car.  The center sill is held at coupler height, with the boards of the flat sitting on top and the tank sitting on those.  Under it is a pair of 4.125 diameter wheels.  Next to the flat, behind Tad is a 5 inch diameter paper towel roll.  This is the same diameter as the goodman cast straight spoke wheels I like.  They do not fit under the flat.  I could have an inside frame and not have the flat stick out.  But then the people have the problem reaching the top of the tank to load it.  They need to stand somewhere.  Raising the flat and tank up will make the car more top heavy and unstable.

The last wheel is my seven inch diameter curly spoke wheel.  While neat I think this will be for an outside frame gravel car.

Ryan

Wednesday, February 18, 2015

Wheels

http://www.bravethinkers.com/Pages_ModelEngineering.asp  I am drooling at his finely detailed spiral spoke wheels.  I sent an email via the web page feb 9th.  -have not heard anything on the 19th

over the pond is the Ffestinion railway.  They use the spiral spoke wheels  I emailed http://www.blackgates.co.uk/  they sent me a picture.  It is 74.60 pounds for 4 blanks  that is $113 in USD today.


http://www.chaski.org/homemachinist/viewtopic.php?f=30&t=99074&view=previous  is a link to a straight spoke wheel.  I emailed the guy Feb 9th  heard back, about $35 to $45 per casting for six inch diameter

http://www.chaski.org/homemachinist/viewtopic.php?f=30&t=98482&view=previous  Nor have I contacted these people.

http://www.chaski.org/homemachinist/viewtopic.php?f=30&t=93957&view=previous  Nor have I asked about these wheels.

http://www.chaski.org/homemachinist/viewtopic.php?f=30&t=95709&view=next  i could ask for some laser cut wheels or something.

https://www.facebook.com/1516604385249445/photos/a.1516623151914235.1073741828.1516604385249445/1535904066652810/?type=1&theater   nice spokes for 18 dollars each.  I keep coming back to these, 5 inch diameter, straight spoke.

Add this to the wheels I have started that are 7.5 inch diameter and I have the potential to have a wide variety of wheels for carts that go with the SBT.  I would love to have a string of ten carts to go with the SBT, at $200 each they would cost about $2000 total.  Quite a bit of cash for something I can not ride on, well maybe with proper design I could ride on them.

Fred w Hanks company sells CNC Steel wheels $18  Cleveland, Ohio.  CNC machined steel wheels. 4.375 tread diameter, .500 reamed axle hole. For more information PM Kevin Harris on facebook.  "We do not stock axles because of the differences in bearing sizes everyone wants to use for bearings. I usually use a 3/8 ID bearing, but others use other ones. It is relatively easy to change the hole size on the wheel, or adjust the un made axle to fit a wheel. It is a bit harder I keep the axle perfectly true when adjusting a bearing surface."

mr-motion.net sells steel wheels machined on a CNC lathe to IBLS wheel standards. ½” center hole. The tread is 4.375” dia. Pricing : for black oxide finish is $20.00 each; for a “raw steel” finish is $18.50 each, plus shipping. Flat back profiled front.

https://sites.google.com/site/eatoncustomengineering/  is $23 per wheel or $69.95 for an axle steel wheel.  I purchased blanks, Robb made axles, and there is a noticeable out of roundness between the bearings and the wheel face.  Flat back profiled front.

plumcovestudios.com is $80 for an axle, cast iron cnc machined.

http://www.realtrains.com/files/83950612.pdf $27 for steel wheel profiled both sides.

http://btilden.com/Products.html  $340 for a set of 8 5" wheels with keyway, good for locomotives. that is $42.50 each

http://railridersupply.com/ has holed wheels for $90 each.  $300 for an axle.  

Saturday, February 14, 2015

Center Sills

Today's task was making two centersills for the small tank cars.  If I had made square ends it would have taken about 5 minutes.  But I decided to match the coupler pockets of the SBT.  I think I did a better job on these than I did on the first set on the SBT.


First I cut two eighteen inch sections of 1x2 tube.  Then I used the same template as the SBT to mark the curve.  Then I marked each side one inch in for the flat on the sides.  I then used the band saw to cut 45 degree off each corner.  Then I used the saw to make the flat on the edge, last was cutting the edge out with the bandsaw.  Then on to the hand action cleaning up the cuts with a hacksaw.  Then on to using a file and the bench grinder.  Last was sand paper to clean up everything nicely.
Then I ruined all my hard work by drilling two 5/16th holes on each end, one at the standard place for Tom Bee couplers, the other is for links.  This is the same way as the SBT.  It took some time to clean the holes up, and remove the burrs without damaging the ends.

Wednesday, February 11, 2015

Tank Flat


Today I used my new table saw and my shop vacuum to collect the dust.  I took some pallet wood and ripped all 4 sides on the saw.  I tried out the jointer, but the blades need to be replaced, too many uneven gouges.  Nancy ordered the new blades from Amazon.  

I also had trouble keeping the board flat on the jointer, it seams to rise up / rock at the middle so I end up with a thick middle and thin ends.  I will try some things later, shallower cuts, etc to get better results.  

The end result is a platform / flat car for the tank cars.  They are about 15 inch long, and will be about 11 inches wide.  Trying to decide how far I should go without having wheels... 


Saturday, February 07, 2015

Modifications, New Tools

This past spring I had purchased a pair of 30 inch long tanks 10 inch diameter.  I started dis-assembly  on one of them, to make them more scale in appearance.  removing the top platform, and PVC nozzle.  The three nylon tank bands had to go.  I also removed the oversized mounting blocks.  The last task was to split the tank in half.  Because there was an internal disk at the centerline I used my new table saw and cut just to the right and left.  I was left with two 14.5" tanks, I reused the disk for the end of one of them and got a disk for the other on the bandsaw.  My blade bends outboard as it cuts so it took three tries.  The first two I used a jig to make, the third freehand, it is not a perfect circle, but it is close enough.  Afterword I cut a 3x3 inche piece of pallet wood to fit inside from head to head, this I glued in with gorrila glue and nailed all the staves to the head with the airgun and one inch nails.  

These two tanks will go onto frames to look like industrial tanks on 4 wheel flats similar in size to what the Jeffrey company had.
I am trying to decide if I should use the wheel sets I currently have on hand, on the archbar trucks under the utility flat or get some more.


In other news I showed the girls at Anna's birthday party my crayon art.  One of them begged for this drawing,  I figured it would be better to have it seen than to put it back into storage.  I gave one of the other girls a drawing on canvas.  I hope both of them take care of them.

Thursday, January 01, 2015

O scale Building Kits

This is a Thomas Yorke Rocopila Short Line Stone Depot from 1976, when I was two years old.  One of only 200 made, though I do not know which number because the glue on the label is so old it fell off before I bought the kit.

 The crispness of the castings are incredible.  I would love to take the time to build this kit, to make it my own.



 But I have no place for it after it is built.  It would sit in a box, or on a shelf.  I have done that once with a downtown deco stone station kit.  Having a plaster station sit on a shelf worrying about it, it was a relief to see it placed where it belongs, on a layout, the L&MB.  It does look slightly out of place but I am sure Larry will get it to blend in.  The safest place for a plaster model is on a layout or diorama in a living room. 



 Another interesting kit.




 This one with the mansard roof is not that common, it would take a lot of work to back date it from the 60's to the 1900's for my layout.



 I could imagine spending hours detailing this kit.

 The same with these two DPM kits.








Now that I am in 7.5" I have to choose my projects.  I have a choice, I could keep these building kits in a box for years to come, in hopes that I circle back to the desire to building an O scale layout that needs these buildings.  Or I can sell them and use the money on trains I use now and enjoy now.  As long as they sell for at least what I bought them for I will be happy.  I may be sad to never have built the Yorke kit, but other than high quality plaster castings it is just like any other kit.